In his new book, The Greatest Story Ever Sold, Frank Rich dismisses the popular notion that George W. Bush is stupid, and makes a penetrating observation:
[T]here was plenty of evidence to suggest that Bush was no dunce. His mediocre grades at Yale — which he tried to keep private — were indistinguishable from those of the showily wonky Gore at Harvard. The problem with Bush was not that he was stupid but that he thought everyone else was stupid.
There’s a lot of that going around.
Rich continues:
He believed he could sell anything if he repeated the pitch often enough (and often verbatim).
On left-wing blogs, conservatives and Republicans are idiots. On right-wing blogs, liberals and Democrats are morons. On both sides, everyone in the middle is uninformed or ill-informed or just plain dense — otherwise, they would agree with me.
“I harangue and I harangue, but do you listen?”
Homer Simpson expressed the mindset admirably, explaining why something had been done the way it was: “Because they’re stupid, that’s why. That’s why everybody does everything!”
Oh, I’m guilty, too. As a Macintosh zealot, I am morally obligated to pity those poor souls who use Microsoft Windows. It’s not their fault, really — they just don’t know any better. For their part, Windows users seem to view Mac people with scorn, more than pity.
The belief that everyone else is stupid seems deeply ingrained. I can’t tell whether it’s a trait of human nature, of the American character, or just of the particular bunch of jerks I keep running into.
What’s the benefit of recognizing stupidity in others? It’s a great time-saver. You don’t have to waste your time listening to morons or explaining your own views to idiots.
The problem is that the only way to determine whether someone is worth listening to is to listen to him for a while. It seems, increasingly, that we’ve cut out that step. We never listen, so we never learn. That makes us ineducable.
“Ineducable.” Yeah, it’s a big word. I’m not stupid. I’m just incapable of learning anything, which is completely different.